Bias in culture-independent assessments of microbial biodiversity in the global ocean

On the basis of 16S rRNA gene sequencing, the SAR11 clade of marine bacteria has almost universal distribution, being detected as abundant sequences in all marine provinces. Yet SAR11 sequences are rarely detected in fosmid libraries, suggesting that the widespread abundance may be an artefact of PCR cloning and that SAR 11 has a relatively low abundance. Here the relative abundance of SAR11 is explored in both a fosmid library and a metagenomic sequence data set from the same biological community taken from fjord surface water from Bergen, Norway. Pyrosequenced data and 16S clone data confirmed an 11-15% relative abundance of SAR11 within the community. In contrast not a single SAR11 fosmid was identified in a pooled shotgun sequenced data set of 100 fosmid clones. This under-representation was evidenced by comparative abundances of SAR11 sequences assessed by taxonomic annotation; functional metabolic profiling and fragment recruitment. Analysis revealed a similar under-representation of low-GC Flavobacteriaceae. We speculate that the fosmid bias may be due to DNA fragmentation during preparation due to the low GC content of SAR11 sequences and other underrepresented taxa. This study suggests that while fosmid libraries can be extremely useful, caution must be used when directly inferring community composition from metagenomic fosmid libraries

Prevalence and Evolution of Core Photosystem II Genes in Marine Cyanobacterial Viruses and Their Hosts

Cyanophages (cyanobacterial viruses) are important agents of horizontal gene transfer among marine cyanobacteria, the numerically dominant photosynthetic organisms in the oceans. Some cyanophage genomes carry and express host-like photosynthesis genes, presumably to augment the host photosynthetic machinery during infection. To study the prevalence and evolutionary dynamics of this phenomenon, 33 cultured cyanophages of known family and host range and viral DNA from field samples were screened for the presence of two core photosystem reaction center genes, psbA and psbD. Combining this expanded dataset with published data for nine other cyanophages, we found that 88% of the phage genomes contain psbA, and 50% contain both psbA and psbD. The psbA gene was found in all myoviruses and Prochlorococcus podoviruses, but could not be amplified from Prochlorococcus siphoviruses or Synechococcus podoviruses. Nearly all of the phages that encoded both psbA and psbD had broad host ranges. We speculate that the presence or absence of psbA in a phage genome may be determined by the length of the latent period of infection. Whether it also carries psbD may reflect constraints on coupling of viral- and host-encoded PsbA–PsbD in the photosynthetic reaction center across divergent hosts. Phylogenetic clustering patterns of these genes from cultured phages suggest that whole genes have been transferred from host to phage in a discrete number of events over the course of evolution (four for psbA, and two for psbD), followed by horizontal and vertical transfer between cyanophages. Clustering patterns of psbA and psbD from Synechococcus cells were inconsistent with other molecular phylogenetic markers, suggesting genetic exchanges involving Synechococcus lineages. Signatures of intragenic recombination, detected within the cyanophage gene pool as well as between hosts and phages in both directions, support this hypothesis. The analysis of cyanophage psbA and psbD genes from field populations revealed significant sequence diversity, much of which is represented in our cultured isolates. Collectively, these findings show that photosynthesis genes are common in cyanophages and that significant genetic exchanges occur from host to phage, phage to host, and within the phage gene pool. This generates genetic diversity among the phage, which serves as a reservoir for their hosts, and in turn influences photosystem evolution

Molecular Identification of Atlantic Bluefin Tuna (Thunnus thynnus, Scombridae) Larvae and Development of a DNA Character-Based Identification Key for Mediterranean Scombrids

The Atlantic bluefin tuna, Thunnus thynnus, is a commercially important species that has been severely over-exploited in the recent past. Although the eastern Atlantic and Mediterranean stock is now showing signs of recovery, its current status remains very uncertain and as a consequence their recovery is dependent upon severe management informed by rigorous scientific research. Monitoring of early life history stages can inform decision makers about the health of the species based upon recruitment and survival rates. Misidentification of fish larvae and eggs can lead to inaccurate estimates of stock biomass and productivity which can trigger demands for increased quotas and unsound management conclusions. Herein we used a molecular approach employing mitochondrial and nuclear genes (CO1 and ITS1, respectively) to identify larvae (n = 188) collected from three spawning areas in the Mediterranean Sea by different institutions working with a regional fisheries management organization. Several techniques were used to analyze the genetic sequences (sequence alignments using search algorithms, neighbour joining trees, and a genetic character-based identification key) and an extensive comparison of the results is presented. During this process various inaccuracies in related publications and online databases were uncovered. Our results reveal important differences in the accuracy of the taxonomic identifications carried out by different ichthyoplanktologists following morphology- based methods. While less than half of larvae provided were bluefin tuna, other dominant taxa were bullet tuna (Auxis rochei), albacore (Thunnus alalunga) and little tunny (Euthynnus alletteratus). We advocate an expansion of expertise for a new generation of morphology-based taxonomists, increased dialogue between morphology-based and molecular taxonomists and increased scrutiny of public sequence databases.Versión del editor4,411

A shallow scattering layer structures the energy seascape of an open ocean predator.

Large predators frequent the open ocean where subsurface light drives visually based trophic interactions. However, we lack knowledge on how predators achieve energy balance in the unproductive open ocean where prey biomass is minimal in well-lit surface waters but high in dim midwaters in the form of scattering layers. We use an interdisciplinary approach to assess how the bioenergetics of scattering layer forays by a model predator vary across biomes. We show that the mean metabolic cost rate of daytime deep foraging dives to scattering layers decreases as much as 26% from coastal to pelagic biomes. The more favorable energetics offshore are enabled by the addition of a shallow scattering layer that, if not present, would otherwise necessitate costlier dives to deeper layers. The unprecedented importance of this shallow scattering layer challenges assumptions that the globally ubiquitous primary deep scattering layer constitutes the only mesopelagic resource regularly targeted by apex predators

Improved group-specific PCR primers for denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis of the genetic diversity of complex microbial communities

Phylum- and class-specific PCR primers were tested for the production of clone libraries and for denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) analysis of complex bacterial communities. Primers were designed to specifically amplify 16S rRNA gene fragments of the phyla Bacteroidetes, Planctomycetes and Firmicutes, of three classes of the phylum Proteobacteria, the Alphaproteo-bacteria, Betaproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria, and of the Cyanobacteria (including chloroplast 16S rRNA genes). The specificity of the seven primer pairs was tested by producing clone libraries from environmental DNA samples from mesotrophic (Norwegian coastal) and oligotrophic (Northern Atlantic Gyre) environments. Five of the seven primer pairs specifically amplified target 16S rRNA gene sequences. Exceptions were the Betaproteobacteria- and Firmicutes-specific primers, which were relatively successful with coastal water mesocosm samples but less so with the Northern Atlantic Gyre sample. Phylogenetic analysis of sequences from the Gammaproteobacteria clone library revealed that the coastal sample yielded a number of clones that clustered within clades that belong to the oligotrophic marine Gammaproteobacteria (OMG) group, indicating that this group is not confined exclusively to the oligotrophic environment. Comparison of the bacterial diversity of the environmental DNA sample from the coastal and the open ocean using a two- or three-step nested PCR-DGGE process revealed significant differences in the bacterial communities. The application of the group-specific primers provides a higher resolution genetic fingerprinting approach than existing DGGE primer sets

High resolution genetic diversity studies of marine Synechococcus isolates using rpoC1-based restriction fragment length polymorphism

Synechococcus-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers were developed and used to amplify fragments of the RNA polymerase core subunit gene rpoC1 of a set of 23 marine isolates from different oceanographic locations. Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of the PCR products differentiated between most strains and all phylogenetic clades, thus allowing the screening of large sample sets at high genetic resolution. The method was used to analyse changes in the genetic diversity of marine Synechococcus strains through an annual cycle at 100 m depth in the Gulf of Aqaba, Red Sea, and along the depth profile of a sample from June 1999. RFLP analysis of 36 clones of each of the 8 rpoC1 clone libraries screened showed that the Synechococcus population during summer and autumn was dominated by 1 to 3 genetically different clones, while maximum genetic richness was found during spring and winter. Analysis of the depth profile during the period of stratification revealed differences in relative abundance of particular RFLP types among depths (10, 30, 100 m), although the same genotypes dominated the assemblage throughout. Multivariate analysis of environmental variables and Synechococcus assemblage composition showed that Synechococcus genetic diversity was most closely, and significantly, correlated to a combination of temperature and NO3- (P = 0.645, p = 0.038). Phylogenetic analysis of the marine rpoC1 nucleotide sequences of the 40 different RFLP types identified in this study, and all Synechococcus rpoC1 sequences in the databases, demonstrates that the new PCR primers amplify rpoC1 gene fragments from all MC-A and some Cyanobium lineages of marine Synechococcus strains and are also useful for the identification of potentially novel lineages